Footwear Affects the Behavior of Low Back Muscles When Jogging

Use of modified shoes and insole materials has been widely advocated to treat low back symptoms from running impacts, although considerable uncertainty remains regarding the effects of these devices on the rate of shock transmission to the spine. This study investigated the effects of shoes and insole materials on a) the rate of shock transmission to the spine, b) the temporal response of spinal musculature to impact loading, and c) the time interval between peak lumbar acceleration and peak lumbar muscle response. It was hypothesised that shoes and inserts a) decrease the rate of shock transmission, b) decrease the low back muscle response time, and c) shorten the time interval between peak lumbar acceleration and peak lumbar muscle response. Twelve healthy subjects were tested while jogging barefoot (unshod) or wearing identical athletic shoes (shod). Either no material, semi-rigid (34 Shore A), or soft (9.5 Shore A) insole material covered the force plate in the barefoot conditions and was placed as insole when running shod. Ground reaction forces, acceleration at the third lumbar level, and erector spinae myoelectric activity were recorded simultaneously. The rate of shock transmission to the spine was greater (p < 0.0003) unshod (acceleration rate: Means ± SD 127.35 ± 87.23 g/s) than shod (49.84 ± 33.98 g/s). The temporal response of spinal musculature following heel strike was significantly shorter (p < 0.023) unshod (0.038 ± 0.021 s) than shod (0.047 ± 0.036 s). The latency between acceleration peak (maximal external force) and muscle response peak (maximal internal force) was significantly (p < 0.021) longer unshod (0.0137 ± 0.022 s) than shod (0.004 ± 0.040 s). These results suggest that one of the benefits of running shoes and insoles is improved temporal synchronization between potentially destabilizing external forces and stabilizing internal forces around the lumbar spine.

Key words:

Running injuries, shoes, low backpain, insoles.

References

• 1 Aleksiev A, Pope M H, Hooper D, Wilder D G, Magnusson M, Goel V K, Weinstein J, Lee S, Spratt K. Pelvic unlevelness in low back patients - biomechanics and EMG time-frequency analysis: The 1995 Vienna Award for Physical Medicine.  Eur J Phys Med Rehabil. 1996;  6 3-16
• 2 Bullock-Saxton J E, Janda V, Bullock M I. Reflex activation of gluteal muscles in walking. An approach to restoration of muscle function for patients with low-back pain.  Spine. 1993;  18 704-708
• 3 Chen C P, Lakes R S. Design of viscoelastic impact absorbers: Optimal material properties.  Int J Solids Structures. 1990;  26 1313-1328
• 4 Clarke T E, Frederick E C, Cooper L B. Effects of shoe cushioning upon ground reaction forces in running.  Int J Sports Med. 1983;  4 247-251
• 5 Dickinson J A, Cook S D, Leinhardt T M. The measurement of shock waves following heel strike while running.  J Biomech. 1985;  18 415-422
• 6 Dolan H P, Adams M A. The relationship between EMG activity and extensor moment generation in the erector spinae muscles during bending and lifting activities.  J Biomech. 1993;  26 513-522
• 7 Forner A, Garcia A C, Alcantara E, Ramiro J, Hoyos J V, Vera P. Properties of shoe insert materials related to shock wave transmission during gait.  Foot Ankle Int. 1995;  16 778-789
• 8 Horak F B, Nashner L M. Central programming of postural movements: adaptation to altered support-surface configurations.  J Neurophysiol. 1986;  55 1369-1381
• 9 Light L H, McLellan G E, Klenerman L. Skeletal transients on heel strike in normal walking with different footwear.  J Biomech. 1980;  13 477-480
• 10 Kim W, Voloshin A S, Johnson S H, Simkin A. Measurement of impulsive bone motion by skin-mounted accelerometers.  J Biomech Eng. 1993;  115 47-52
• 11 Nigg B M, Bahlsen A H, Denoth J, Luethi S M, Stacoff A. Factors influencing kinetic and kinematic variables in running. In: Nigg BM (ed) Biomechanics of Running Shoes. Champaign IL; Human Kinetics Publishers 1986: 139-159
• 12 Nigg B M, Herzog W, Read L J. Effect of viscoelastic shoe insoles on vertical impact forces in heel-toe running.  Am J Sports Med. 1988;  164 70-76
• 13 McGill S M. Electromyographic activity of the abdominal and low back musculature during the generation of isometric and dynamic axial trunktorque: implications for lumbar mechanics.  J Orthop . 1991;  9 91-103
• 14 Pope M H, Broman H, Hansson T. The impact response of the standing subject- a feasibility study.  Clin Biomech. 1989;  4 195-200
• 15 Radin E L, Paul I L, Rose R M. Role of mechanical factors in pathogenesis of primary osteoarthritis.  Lancet. 1972;  1 519-521
• 16 Radin E L, Eyre D, Kelman J L, Schiller A L. Effect of prolonged walking on concrete on joints of sheep.  Arthritis Rheum. 1979;  22 649
• 17 Radin L R, Yang K H, Rieger C, Kish V L, O’Connor J J. Relationship between lower limb dynamics and knee joints pain.  J Orthop Res. 1991;  9 398-405
• 18 Robbins S E, Hanna A M. Running-related injury prevention through barefoot adaptations.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1987;  19 148-156
• 19 Robbins S E, Gouw G J. Athletic footwear and chronic overloading. A brief review.  Sports Med. 1990;  9 76-85
• 20 Robbins S E, Gouw G J, Hanna A M. Running-related injury prevention through innate impact-moderating behavior.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1989;  2 130-139
• 21 Robbins S E, Hanna A M, Gouw G J. Overload protection. Avoidance response to heavy plantar surface loading.  Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1988;  20 85-92
• 22 Saha S, Lakes R. The effect of soft tissue on wave propagation and vibration tests for determing the in vivo properties of bone.  J Biomech. 1977;  10 393-401
• 23 Schmidt R. Motor Learning and Performance. From Principles to Practice. Champaign, Illinois; Human Kinetics Publishers 1991
• 24 Smeathers J E. Measurement of transmissibility for the human spine during walking and running.  Clin Biomech. 1989;  4 34-40
• 25 Voloshin A S, Wosk J. In vivo study of low back pain and shock absorption in human locomotion system.  J Biomech. 1982;  15 21-27
• 26 Wosk J, Voloshin A S. Low back pain: Conservative treatment with artificial shock absorbers.  Arch Phys Med Rehabil. 1985;  66 145-148
• 27 Ziegert J C, Lewis J L. The effect of soft tissue on measurements of vibrational bone motion by skin-mounted accelerometers.  J Biomech Eng. 1979;  101 210-218